Title 255—LOCAL
COURT RULESCARBON COUNTY Amendment of Civil Case Management Plan; 04-1823 [44 Pa.B. 3086]
[Saturday, May 24, 2014]Administrative Order No. 11-2014 And Now, this 6th day of May, 2014, it is hereby
Ordered and Decreed that, effective July 1, 2014, Carbon County Amends the Civil Case Management Plan as follows.
The Carbon County District Court Administrator is Ordered and Directed to do the following:
1. File one (1) certified copy of this Administrative Order with the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts.
2. File two (2) certified copies and one (1) diskette with the Legislative Reference Bureau for publication in the Pennsylvania Bulletin.
3. File one (1) certified copy with the Pennsylvania Civil Procedural Rules Committee.
4. Forward one (1) copy for publication in the Carbon County Law Journal.
5. Forward one (1) copy to the Carbon County Law Library.
6. Keep continuously available for public inspection copies of the Order in the Prothonotary's Office.
By the Court
ROGER N. NANOVIC,
President JudgeCARBON COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN I. Judicial Commitment to Caseflow Management
Since January 3, 1995, the Court has assumed the responsibility of ensuring the fair and prompt disposition of all cases, as well as assuring effective and efficient use of Court resources paid for by taxpayers. Our success is attributable to the commitment of this principle by each Judge, Court and County staff of the 56th Judicial District.
Goal setting provides the objectives and a benchmark for measuring its success. The Court must meet reasonable time standards for the processing and prompt disposition of standard types of cases in terms of their nature and legal issues. Exhibit ''1,'' attached hereto, shows the timelines and time standards by track for civil cases adopted by this Court.
II. Effective Communications with the Bar
The Court coordinates scheduling of cases and makes reasonable accommodations to attorneys and parties in the management of cases. Operative scheduling allows efficient case processing.
III. Early and Continuous Court Supervision of Case Progress
The Court monitors the progress of cases from the time a writ of summons or complaint is filed to ensure movement of cases to disposition, eliminating unnecessary delay and additional costs of litigation. Mere agreement of counsel/parties is not sufficient grounds for the Court to grant continuances. When a continuance is granted, the matter is continued to a specified date.
IV. Event-Date Certainty
Reasonable certainty about filing deadlines and event dates avoids aggravation, waste and unnecessary cost to the parties and their attorneys. Moreover, national studies have found that nothing promotes pretrial dispositions more than the expectation that a trial is more likely than not to occur on or near the scheduled date. Approximately one hundred twenty days (120) after initial filing of the action, deadlines and events are scheduled with notice given to attorneys/parties of all deadlines and projected event dates, assuring case flow and expeditious case dispositions.
V. A Functional Case Management Information System
The fully automated court computer system provides relevant, accurate, and timely case information, supporting an efficient case management plan by tracking and maintaining cases and events. Monthly reports identify specific cases that have been pending longer than the time standards so appropriate steps can be taken.
VI. Time Standards and Case Management Criteria
A. Court Ruling on Motions
1. Motions are decided pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 208.4.
2. Each Judge monitors the status of all outstanding motions.
3. Semi Annual Reports—Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Judicial Administration 703(B)(2), each Judge is responsible to report on matters submitted and undisposed for 90 days or more.
B. Differentiated Case Management by Case Tracks
Upon the filing of an action, the court computer database assigns a Judge, track and timelines based on the case type, number of parties, and the timeframes established by this Court. These provisions govern each case unless changed at an attorney's request, upon management review by the Office of the District Court Administrator or upon the Court's own directive. If the amount in controversy is less than $50,000.00, the case proceeds on the fast track directly to arbitration.
C. One Hundred Twenty-Day Review
Approximately one hundred twenty (120) days after initial filing of the case, a review of the docket activity is performed to check the status of the case. If the complaint and service are in order, a management review order is produced confirming the timelines established for the case. A management conference is scheduled for cases where the proper pleadings or service have not been initiated.
D. Fast Track
A case is assigned to the fast track when it appears that it can be promptly tried with little pre-trial discovery and other pre-trial proceedings. All cases having four or less parties as shown in Exhibit ''2'' are fast track cases. Except in extraordinary circumstances, the Court strives to dispose of all fast track cases within ten (10) monthsafter initial filing. Upon completion of the discovery period, the case is given a date certain for arbitration or non-jury trial. In any case where an appeal for an arbitration award is filed, the case is given a date certain for a pre-trial conference or non-jury trial. If settlement is not reached at the pre-trial conference, the case is scheduled for trial.
E. Standard Case Track
All cases not designated fast track or complex are standard civil cases. Except in extraordinary circumstances, the Court strives to dispose all standard cases within 18 months after initial filing. Upon completion of the discovery period, the case is given a date certain for a pre-trial conference or non-jury trial. If settlement is not reached at the pre-trial conference, the case is scheduled for trial.
F. Complex Case Track.
A case is assigned to the complex track when additional time and resources are needed to bring the case to disposition. Civil cases involving construction contracts, three or more parties, or claims of asbestos, medical malpractice or products liability are complex cases. Upon completion of the discovery period, the case is given a date certain for a pre-trial conference or non-jury trial. If settlement is not reached at the pre-trial conference, the case is scheduled for trial. Except in extraordinary circumstances, the Court strives to dispose all complex cases within 24 months after initial filing.
Exhibit ''1'' Case Event/Timelines Fast Track Standard Track Complex Track Management Review Order or Management Conference 4 months 4 months 4 months Discovery Complete 6 months 13 months 18 months Plaintiff Expert Reports 6 months 13 months 19 months Defendant Expert Reports 8 months 14 months 20 months Motions Filing Deadline 8 months 14 months 20 months Pretrial Memorandum Due Approx. 15 months Approx. 21 months Pretrial Settlement Conference (If Jury Trial) 16 months 22 months Jury/Non-Jury Trial 10 months 18 months 24 months Exhibit ''2'' CASE MANAGEMENT TRACK CRITERIA Case Type Number of Parties Management Track Disposition Within Assault, Battery
Premises Liability, Slip & Fall
Other Personal Injury
Torts to Land
Motor Vehicle Property Damage
Other Personal Property Damage
Motor Vehicle Accident (under $25,000)
Insurance, Declaratory Judgment
Negotiable Instruments
Recovery of Overpayment
Contracts for Goods
Other Contract
Foreclosure
Rent, Lease, Ejectment
Title to Real Property
Replevin
Appeals from District Justice
Mechanic's Lien
Other: Consumer or Credit
<4 Fast 10 months Employment/Wrongful Discharge
Assault, Battery
Premises Liability, Slip & Fall
Other Personal Injury
Torts to Land
Motor Vehicle Property Damage
Other Personal Property Damage
Motor Vehicle Accident (under $25,000)
Insurance, Declaratory Judgment
Negotiable Instruments
Recovery of Overpayment
Contracts for Goods
Other Contract
Foreclosure
Partition
Right to Know
Rent, Lease, Ejectment
Title to Real Property
Other: Consumer or Credit
>4 Standard <18 months Fraud
Truth in LendingAny Number Standard <18 months Class Action
Construction Contracts
Medical Malpractice
Toxic Waste, Contamination & Environmental
Professional Malpractice
Toxic Tort Personal Injury
Stockholders Suits
Defamation, Discrimination, Malicious Prosecution
Motor Vehicle Accident (over $25,000.00)
Motor Vehicle Product Liability
Product Liability
Product Liability Property Damage
Contract Product Liability
Any Number Complex <24 months [Pa.B. Doc. No. 14-1082. Filed for public inspection May 23, 2014, 9:00 a.m.]
